Fenton house is so-so for pizza.
Sagebrush is OK for mexican.
We both like the Laundry for something different. They have excellent salads and a variety of non normal meals. Breakfast there is also good.
Don't forget Uncle Ray's for ice cream.
Haven't tried Black Rock. I guess we'll have to give it a whirl.
T-Bonz is a great summer place if you get a table on the deck facing the lake.