I finally decided to post my mine for sale "for real" instead of just feeling the market. The driving force behind it is I just don't use it. Once I put 60's under it, it just sits in the garage. My wife and kids lost all interest because they weren't into the harder obstacles. We have decided to buy a JKU in the next couple years. I will probably get a Rubicon and put it on 35's max.
I know your situation is a little different as your not looking to downsize. I think if you are going back and forth I would just keep it. I finally came to terms it is time for it to go.
2012 JKU Rubicon
37's, 2.5 lift, 4.88 gears, ready to cruise the mall
Run of the mill YJ with Dana 60's and Irok's..SOLD
96 XJ on 38's...SOLD