We have all been then. Do one thing then you want more. I started out with a bone stock toyota then 33's - 38's and lockers - 37's and v8- and now i have 44s, double beadlocks, d60s and possible 4link getting ready to put in.
I have my 36" hummer tires that i plan on swapping back and forth with the 44s just cuz none of the people i wheel with have stuff nearlly as done up as me. Just so were doing some of the similar things and to have more of a challange for certin things.
And 37 is the new 35 is so true. Even look at it on the bigger tires. 54s and 49s are the new 44s. Rockwells are the new 60s, 60s the new 44s, and on and on
But in the end i sure wouldnt mind having a samuri or tracker on 33s or 35s to play around with, small, cheap and easy